Friday, 24 July 2015

Pastures of Pakistan

PASTURE RESOURCE OF PAKISTAN

The total pasture area in different parts of Pakistan is presented in below table-1. Due to misuse and centuries of overgrazing, the productivity of rangelands has been adversely affected. FAO (1987) has reported a critical stocking rate of 16 ha/animal unit for low potential ranges. At present, rangelands are producing only 10 to 15% of their potential. This low productivity can be increased by adopting various management practices such as periodic closures, re-seeding, and improved grazing management etc. Small-holders raise ruminants in limited numbers in conjunction with food and cash crop production. Although cropping patterns vary from region to region, they dictate forage quantity and quality throughout the year.

Pastures resources in irrigated areas
In this system, cut-and-carry feeding plays a vital role in ruminant production. Every farmer allocates a piece of land for planting fodder crops in irrigated areas of Pakistan. Usually milking buffaloes and cows are stall-fed with green fodder and concentrates. The non-milking and draught animals are maintained on straws, maize stovers, and community grazing lands. During summer, most land is planted with sorghum, maize, cotton, rice, and sugarcane. Forage sorghum, millet, and maize provide the bulk of fodder for stall-feeding. Most of the area after rice and cotton harvest remains in fallow and is used for grazing of volunteer species. During winter every farmer plants mixtures of Egyptian clover (Trifolium aegyptium) and oats (Avena sativa) according to the land holding and herd size. Mixtures of berseem (Trifolium alexandrinum) with rice and wheat straw also provide feed during winter. Other crop residues such as dry maize and sorghum stalks, sugar cane tops, and rice stubble are also a component of livestock diets. With the increased demand for milk, meat, and other dairy products, some farmers cultivate large areas with lucerne (Medicago sativa), berseem, oats, maize, and sorghum around the big cities and sell green fodder to farmers raising buffaloes and dairy cows. Urban cattle also graze on vegetable and fruit wastes. Community and government wastelands are utilized to some extent.

Pasture resources in rainfed areas
Nearly 24% of the rainfed tract of the country is unfit for agronomic or forestry crops due to unfavourable soil or climatic conditions. These large areas of land produce grasses and bush. Livestock alone are capable of utilizing this extensive and renewable natural resource. Animal husbandry thus occupies a vital place in the economy of the rainfed areas. Natural grazing on the vast rangelands provides about 20% of the nutritional requirements of cattle and 60% of that of sheep and goats. The flocks and herds of the land-less farmers subsist almost entirely on the rangelands. However, they have been badly over-grazed, and palatable species of grass have perished and been replaced by vegetation that livestock do not relish. The carrying capacity of rangelands has thus been greatly reduced to 10 to 50% of potential.

Table-1: Area or Rangelands in Pakistan
Province
Total Area (M ha)
Rangeland Area (M ha)
Percentage of Provincial Area (%)
Balochistan
34.7
27.4
79
Sindh
14.1
7.8
55
Punjab
20.6
8.2
40
KPK
10.2
6.1
60
Northern Areas
7.0
2.1
30
Azad Kashmir
1.3
0.6
45
Total
88.0
45.2
51
Source: FAO, Pakistan.

The number of animals grazed is 3–4 times the carrying capacity of the rangelands. This not only causes a very poor state of health and production of livestock, but also widespread denudation and damage from water and wind erosion. The situation is further aggravated by the seasonal migration of large numbers of animals belonging to nomadic grazers, such as the Bakarwals from Kaghan (who spend the winter in the Pothwar and salt grass rangelands) and the nomadic tribes from Baluchistan and even Afghanistan in the D.G. Khan piedmont areas. The herders exploit the rangelands and contribute little to the conservation, sustainable utilization or improvement of the rangelands. Supplementary feed must be provided to the livestock, especially during periods of drought and scarcity. For instance, perennial grasses, such as sudan grass, Bajra Napier hybrid, or sorghum hybrids could be grown on part of the cultivated land. Green fodder from these crops could be cut during the dry periods to improve feed supply during the lean period. Rapeseed can provide green fodder during January and February, even in drier areas. A system of mixed farming is practised in some areas of this system, with crop and livestock husbandry very intimately integrated. This is reflected in the cropping pattern. Although separate areas of land are not set aside for fodder crops, there is often an admixture of crops with a view to obtaining some fodder for supplemental feeding of livestock. In large parts of the Barani areas during winter, the wheat and barley crops have admixtures of rapeseed, chickpeas, and mustards. The summer crops have admixtures of maize, millets, sorghum, and guar. Some part of every crop is fed to livestock. This pattern of agriculture has several effects:

• Makes it possible for nutrients from the soil to be derived from two levels due to differing depths of the root systems.
• Increases soil fertility by combining cereals with leguminous crops that have the ability to increase soil nitrogen through the microbes in their root systems.
• Avoids total crop failure in case of absence of rains because of the generally lower water requirements of the crops from which fodder is obtained. One or two cuttings are often obtained from wheat etc. for fodder purposes. This cropping pattern has evolved to meet the food and market requirements in a traditional setting.

Pasture resources in natural rangelands
The vegetation of Pakistan has great complexity, comprising a wide variety of vegetation types, including desert, tropical, Mediterranean, and temperate ecosystems. These rangelands extend from temperate alpine pastures in the northern areas, to Mediterranean rangelands in the western mountains, and to the semi-arid and desert lands of the Indus Valley. Elevation ranges from sea level in the Thar Desert of Sindh Province to over 8800 m in the northern mountain region of the Himalayas. The rangelands of Pakistan have been divided into five major groups (FAO, 1987; Mohammad, 1989; Umrani et al., 1995). A brief description of each group is given below.

(a) Sub-alpine temperate zone. This zone lies between 2 000 m altitude and the snow line in Azad Jammu, Kashmir, Swat, Kaghan valleys, and northern areas. These areas provide excellent forage for livestock grazing during summer growing seasons (Khan, 1979). The major improved grass species found in the rangelands are Festuca arundinacea, Lolium spp., and Potarium sanguiserba.
(b) Sub-tropical humid zone. The sub-tropical humid zone is represented by chir pine forests but kail forests also occur on relatively higher slopes in Northern Pakistan and Azad Kashmir. The altitude varies from 1 000 to 2 000 m. Winters are very cold and grazing is only possible for 2–3 months during the summer season. The dominant introduced grass species are Chloris gayana and Dicanthium annulatum.
(c) Sub-tropical sub-humid zone. The sub-tropical sub-humid zone covers Pothwar tract and the Salt Range. Soil erosion is a major problem. The zone has high potential for range re-seeding. The major introduced grass species include Chrysopogon aucheri, Chyrosopogon montanus, Panicum antidotale, Cenchrus ciliaris, Cymbopogon jawarancusa, Pennisetum lanatum, Cynodon dactylon, Saccharum apontaneum and Aristida depressa.
(d) Arid, semi-arid desert plains. The Thal, Cholistan, D. G. Khan and Tharparker are located in this zone. High temperatures and wind erosion are major constraints. Rangelands in this zone have been heavily over-grazed by local livestock. The major introduced grass species are Cenchrus ciliaris, Lasiurus sindicus, and Pennisetum orientale.
(e) Mediterranean zone. The high lands of Balochistan including Quetta and Kalat Divisions are located in the zone. Low and erratic rainfall of less than 300 mm is received during winter. Nomadic and local livestock graze these rangelands heavily. The important grass species include Agropyron desertorum, Chrysopogon aucheri, and Elmus junceus.

Seed Production for Pasture Species

Pakistan possesses optimum climatic conditions for seed production of various pasture species. Despite a range of research programmes in all four Provinces of Pakistan, conscious efforts have not been made to produce sufficient quantities of seeds of the required forage grasses and legumes. The main reason may be absence of a local market for pasture seeds. On the other hand, Pakistan produces sufficient quantities of seeds of cultivated fodder cereals and legumes (Khan and Bhatti, 1996). Also, private seed companies produce and import seeds of some cultivated fodder crops.

Wednesday, 8 July 2015

Community Displacement due to Diamer Bhasha Dam

Rationale:

The project is located on Indus River, about 315 km upstream of Tarbela Dam, 165 km downstream of the Northern Area capital Gilgit and 40 km downstream of Chilas. The proposed dam would have a maximum height of 270 m, and imvpound a reservoir of about 7,500,000 acre feet (9.25×109 m3), with live storage of more than 6,400,000 acre feet (7.89×109 m3). Mean annual discharge of Indus River at the site is 50,000,000 acre feet (6.2×1010 m3). Thus the dam will impound 15% of the annual river flow. The dam project would cover an area of 110 km2 and extend 100 km upstream of the damsite up to Raikot Bridge on Karakoram Highway (KKH).

WAPDA was initially considering construction of the project offices, laboratories and residential colony for Diamer Basha Dam Project in District Kohistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. However, due to demand of affectees of Thore Valley District Diamer, Gilgit-Baltistan, the location of the project offices, laboratories and residential colony was changed from Kohistan to Thore Valley in Diamer district, on a commitment that the affectees would vacate their houses voluntarily as and when needed by WAPDA for Civil Works. After payment of land compensation they would settle at the places of their choice on their own. It was further agreed between WAPDA and affectees of Thore valley that they would not claim any resettlement in model villages to be developed by WAPDA for the affactees of DBD Project. On this understanding, the Thore valley was not included in the Resettlement Action Plan in terms of any resettlement package except compensation pertaining to price of land and other assets lost by the affectees.

The Chairman directed the General Manager (LA&R) and his team of Specialists to visit Thore valley district Diamer, interact with the affectees and formulate a Corrective Action Plan for the resettlement and rehabilitating of the affectees after their consultation with the stakeholders. The LA&R team under the supervision of GM (LA&R) paid several interactive visits to the Thore Valley. They carried out social mapping of the affected population, collected social-economic data and carried out need assessment and household survey. The team met with district administration, line agencies, MLAs, elders and Ulemas. They also had several meetings with the affectees, discussed resettlement issues with them and finally called a large Jirga meeting in which various decisions were taken. Based on the socioeconomic survey, consultation, discussion sessions and need assessment with the affectees, Jirga members, notables, administration of Diamer District (Chilas), a Corrective Action Plan for resettlement and rehabilitation of affectees of Thore Valley has been prepared.[1]
Following discussed are the issues of the community displacement and the compensations offered to them by the Government.

Landlessness:
The land acquisition of Thore valley for the construction of project colony has been completed. It was sorted that out of the total 2200 there are 970 households which were affected the most and have been paid compensation besides the other 1330 as the first phase of financial disbursement. After receiving price of land, out of total 970 families affected due to this first intervention, their houses were vacated. Remaining  families which are residing still in their old dwellings at site have demanded that they may not be displaced from their houses till they are properly resettled.

Joblessness:
The displaced community faced an acute disturbance of the employment and hence it was supposed by the Government officials to compensate them by hiring the locals for Dam development jobs from BPS[2] Grade 1 to 10 in the construction activities in WAPDA colony. Therefore, it was that these people should be given employment compensation in Thore valley.

Homelessness:
Interaction of LA&R team with affectees of Thore Valley and other stakeholders and consultative process to ascertain their resettlement issues and their probable solutions. In accordance with the directions of the Chairman WAPDA, the GM (LA&R) spear headed his LA&R team and proceeded to Diamer Chilas (G-B) and thereafter interacted with the affectees of Thore Valley (131 households) who have recently been affected by the first intervention of construction of Project Colony of Diamer Basha Dam Project.

Marginalization:
As the USA had agreed to provide $200 million for Basha dam.[3] The lead syndicate for Diamer-Bhasha dam under Asian Development Bank had been established and had asked the WAPDA officials to fill gaps by focusing more on social aspects of the displaced population and placing dispute resolution mechanism for making this project ‘bankable’ for international investors.

Food security:
Due to shortage of land and wheat being the major staple food, the quota must be doubled for the affectees of Thore valley. WAPDA must carry out some Water Supply schemes which should be done for the affectees of Thore Colony who had temporarily settled at other remote locations of the valley. The contractors must be asked to avoid polluting waters of Thore stream as people living downstream cannot use the same water for drinking. In the feasibility by the government of Pakistan, It was settled that an area of 6.1 kilometers would be given to the communities for their agricultural wellbeing and 30 veterinary clinics would be established with 8 full time veterinary doctors and skilled attendants for each of the veterinary clinic.[4]

Morbidity and mortality:
A team of eight doctors from WAPDA Hospital, Lahore comprising of Eye Specialist, Child Specialist, General Physician and Medical Officers was deployed at the camp. Total 925 patients including 231 males, 278 female and 416 children upto age of 12 years were treated in the camp. Free medicines were supplied to all the patients who came for treatment in the camps. Hence there is an unavailability of the healthcare facilities, not reported with any of the sources. It is observed that the mortality and morbidity data is absent for the region from before the project initiation.

Loss of access to common property resource:
As the community displacement mostly covered the agriculture land loss followed by the educational infrastructures. It was settled that the children of affectees of Thore valley should be given admission in the School and Colleges of WAPDA colony. Community Madrassa Schools will be developed as the Government system of school education for girls is not acceptable to the community for various reasons. Hence, on the recommendations and aspirations of the affectees, the Community Madrassa School for girls would also be established. It was proposed that a special quota must be given to the affectees’ children in Medical Colleges all over the country as a sign of compensation and their contribution for the nation building.

Addition to that, a 100 kilometers compensation was provided to the communities as the relief of their property rights drained under the dam area.[5]

Community disarticulation
The overall displacement constitute 30 villages containing to nearly 2200 households. The average members per household were assessed 10 individuals and the statistics showed that there were 22000 population affected by the project implementation. The influence of the project was mainly focused on 97 households leaving the rest to switch to the resources instead of resettlement. The displaced community faced the dilemma of loss of 1500 acres of agricultural land. The reservoir would cover an area of 25000 acres. Nine new settlements were proposed by the government official team for the communities compensation for the agriculture and resettlements. Though the objectives of the dam construction mainly covers the hydroelectric production for nation need based resource. [6]

On April 4, 2008, it was reported in several major South Asian newspapers that Buddhist artifacts, possibly numbering in the thousands, have been recovered at the site of the Diamer-Basha Dam. According to certain reports, the beleaguered engineering firm Lahmeyer International, which has been involved in planning out the dam, has suggested a museum be built to house the artifacts. Also, an unnamed German scholar affiliated with a German archaeological university (possibly the German Archaeological Institute) has traveled to Pakistan to study the artifacts.

The Government of Pakistan has now decided to secure and relocate all items of archaeological significance from the areas that will be inundated by the Diamer-Bhasha Dam and its reservoir and to place them in a newly constructed museum near the Dam site. The history reveals that this incident took place in the era of Great Asoka when the Buddhism was shifted to the Afghan region.



[1] Monitoring Report of Diamer Bhasha Dam, WAPDA, 2009.
[2] Basic Pay Scale
[5] ADB, rerpot, 2006.
[6] The official website of the project: http://www.diamerbhasha.com/aboutbhasha.html

Menu